The+Mysterious+Benedict+Society

Discussion page for //The Mysterious Benedict Society

This was a "cute" read but not high school material. Sue-MHSLMC

I found this a complete bore. I tried to listen on audio and just wanted the author to get to the point. Slow and cumbersome. I haven't any kids asking for the sequel (which is out)...which tells me they didn't like the first one enough to continue reading the series. Amy Inglis, Barrington

Amy, I'm with you on this!!! What a terrific bore, and definitely for a younger audience. Not really Flume material. Lisa Houde / Rye Public Library

Definitely too young for the Isinglass List. I, too, was bored reading this. It could have been developed to a great potential, but it just never happened. Pat Adams/Chesley Memorial Library

I personally wanted this to be better than it was. It could've been great. But it wasn't. -- Julie Andrews | Nashua Public Library

I will have to disagree about this being boring. I thought it was a thoughtful novel that many of our readers enjoyed. We have gotten all three books because our kids really enjoy them and we have also started getting them on audio. I do have to agree that these mostly appeal to the younger ages though moreso than the older kids. These books do not inclide enough social issues or fantasy to be a big hit with teens. -B.Moore Hall Memorial Library

I also enjoyed this book (& our director LOVED them), but I agree that it is definitely on the younger side- we have a 2nd copy in our children's room. -Lucia, Wiggin Memorial Library, Stratham//